April 21, 2026
Volume 101
Kimberly R. Kemppainen
The Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) was designed to be one of the most consequential federal transparency reforms in decades. It was enacted to curtail the use of anonymous business entities in money laundering, fraud, and tax abuse and promised to transform beneficial ownership disclosure from a reactive investigative tool into a universal reporting regime. Yet the CTA’s implementation has proven far more complicated and unstable than its legislative ambitions suggested. The statute’s practical significance has been nearly eradicated by enforcement delays, shifting compliance expectations, and sustained constitutional challenges. However, the erosion of the CTA’s regulatory force does not diminish the underlying problem that motivated its enactment. This Note primarily focuses on the CTA’s original reporting framework, which defined the statute’s compliance obligations and cost structure.
This Note evaluates the original CTA through a cost-benefit analysis to explain both its economic implications and institutional instability. This framework is particularly useful in the context of disclosure-based regulation, where policymakers seek to reduce information asymmetries while inevitably imposing compliance burdens. The analysis goes beyond measuring regulatory costs and identifies the conditions under which transparency mandates become inefficient or ineffective. By examining the statute’s original reporting framework, this Note provides both an explanation of the CTA’s trajectory and insight into the design challenges facing future beneficial ownership disclosure regimes.
Despite the CTA’s downsizing, it remains instructive. Its bipartisan origins and continuing constitutional litigation indicate that beneficial ownership transparency will likely remain a recurring feature of regulatory policy. Understanding the economic and institutional dynamics that constrained the CTA is essential for evaluating future disclosure frameworks. Effective reporting regimes require not only legitimate policy objectives but also careful calibration of their expected benefits and costs. In this respect, the CTA serves not only as a regulatory experiment but as a case study in the economic limits of disclosure-based financial regulation.
April 8, 2026
Reviewed by Michael Conklin
This book review was published in the Indiana Law Journal Supplement. To view the official PDF version, click here.
Michael Conklin, A Review of The Future of Free Speech by Jacob Mchangama and Jeff Kosseff, 101 Ind. L.J. Supp. 91 (2026) (reviewing Jacob Mchangama & Jeff Kosseff, The Future of Free Speech: Reversing the Global Decline of Democracy’s Most Essential Freedom (2026)).
Introduction
Debates over free speech have become increasingly polarized, with public discourse often framed in stark terms of either unchecked permissiveness or urgent regulatory intervention. Against this backdrop, Jacob Mchangama and Jeff Kosseff provide much-needed clarity in their new book, The Future of Free Speech: Reversing the Global Decline of Democracy’s Most Essential Freedom.[1] The book will hopefully serve as a powerful catalyst to spark interest in effective free speech advocacy. This Book Review proceeds in two parts. Part I highlights the book’s principal strengths, focusing on the author’s honest assessment of both sides, the unintended consequences of censorship, powerful examples of how bad speech is overcome by more speech, and the pragmatism of taking a global perspective. Part II offers a set of modest, constructive critiques aimed at sharpening the book’s normative claims and clarifying several important doctrinal and policy distinctions.
April 8, 2026
Volume 101
Michael Conklin
Debates over free speech have become increasingly polarized, with public discourse often framed in stark terms of either unchecked permissiveness or urgent regulatory intervention. Against this backdrop, Jacob Mchangama and Jeff Kosseff provide much-needed clarity in their new book, The Future of Free Speech: Reversing the Global Decline of Democracy’s Most Essential Freedom. The book will hopefully serve as a powerful catalyst to spark interest in effective free speech advocacy. This Book Review highlights the book’s principal strengths, focusing on the author’s honest assessment of both sides, the unintended consequences of censorship, powerful examples of how bad speech is overcome by more speech, and the pragmatism of taking a global perspective. It also offers a set of modest, constructive critiques aimed at sharpening the book’s normative claims and clarifying several important doctrinal and policy distinctions.
For scholars, policymakers, and advocates grappling with the future of speech regulation in an increasingly global and technologically mediated public sphere, this book offers both a powerful warning and a constructive framework for thinking more clearly about what is at stake when societies choose censorship over liberty. Through international comparisons, historical context, and practical anecdotes of free speech triumphing over censorship, the authors provide a powerful and much-needed framework for free speech advocacy.