Supplement: 87

Application of Default Rules to Address Financial Conflicts of Interest in Academic Medical Centers

VOLUME 87

Joanna K. Sax

This Essay proposes that the rules governing financial conflicts of interest for scientists within the National Institutes of Health apply to scientists at Academic Medical Centers because scientists at both places receive federal funding. The rules governing financial conflicts of interest within the National Institutes of Health are stricter than the rules at Academic Medical Centers. The cornerstone of financial conflicts of interest rules at Academic Medical Centers is disclosure, which is inadequate. This Essay builds on previous work calling for significant changes to rules addressing financial conflicts of interest, and it promotes changes by calling for the application of stringent rules governing financial conflicts of interest in Academic Medical Centers.

The Irony of AT&T v. Concepcion

VOLUME 87

Colin P. Marks

This Essay explores the possible dual readings of Concepcion in light of the FAA and its interpretation, including Supreme Court precedents.  This Essay concludes that though there is support for interpreting the Concepcion decision narrowly, it is more likely that a broader interpretation was intended, but the metes and bounds of this opinion have yet to be explored.  Nonetheless, under this broad interpretation, the effect on consumers will be to discourage individuals from seeking redress for their claims.  Indeed, the decision may actually encourage businesses to breach contractual obligations with impunity when the individual sums owed are too small to justify— in the mind of a reasonable consumer—the time and effort to seek a remedy.

How Jon Stewart and Lady Gaga Made Congress Less Lame: The Impact of Social Media on the Passage of Bills Through the “Lame Duck” Session of the 111th Congress and Beyond

VOLUME 87

Onika K. Williams

The lame duck 111th Congress saw tremendous action in a relatively short period of time, and it was also witness to a phenomenon of social media. Users on websites such as Facebook and Twitter employed social media to send messages to their representatives and to actively participate in the lame duck session. Jon Stewart used television to advocate for Congress’s passing of the James Zadroga 9/11 Health and Compensation Act, and Lady Gaga employed Twitter to support the Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell Repeal Act of 2010. Both bills subsequently passed Congress. The social media phenomenon did not end with the 111th Congress, however, and the 112th Congress saw issue after issue arise, many stemming at least in part from some aspect of social media. This Congress proved that social media’s influence may not always be positive, but its effect is real and should be contemplated in a serious fashion.

Oklahoma and Beyond: Understanding the Wave of State Anti-Transnational Law Initiatives

VOLUME 87

Martha F. Davis & Johanna Kalb

In the past year, initiatives to block judicial consideration of foreign or international law have been introduced in over half of the states. The proposals vary, ranging from the “softer” versions, which codify existing common law principles governing judicial decision making to the more extreme versions, which aggressively bar all consideration of foreign and international law, virtually eliminating judicial discretion regarding the relevance of such law in a particular case. This Essay contends that in all their variations, these anti-transnational law measures pose serious and fundamental challenges to the American judicial system. They undermine our federalist system by ignoring federal constitutional text specifying that ratified treaties and international customary law are the “supreme Law of the Land,” to be enforced by federal and state courts alike. Moreover, the uncertainty they create could have dramatic impacts on the nation’s ability to conduct foreign policy, international trade,  and national security. The result of these proposals, should they be enacted, would likely be frustration of international business transactions, elimination of judicial discretion in individual cases, and restriction on individual freedom to contract. Far from preserving American values, these proposals would serve to undermine them.