Volume 102
Michael D. Cicchini
Prosecutors, not defendants, employ the vast majority of expert witnesses at criminal trials. However, the stringent Daubert standard of admissibility was supposed to curtail such testimony. But while Daubert has posed a nearinsurmountable barrier for defendants, it has had no effect whatsoever on prosecutors. To build upon the findings of earlier studies, this Article analyzes all appellate cases in a single jurisdiction during a recent five-year span. In 52 cases, there were 115 Daubert decisions across all three levels of the court system, and the state’s record was 111-4 (or 113-2, depending on how a defense victory is defined). Further, courts allowed several categories of expert evidence for the state—e.g., child interview best practices, commonality evidence, and firearms evidence—but excluded that same evidence for the defense, despite the superior credentials of defense experts. Given the gross disparity in outcomes and, more importantly, the courts’ disingenuous reasoning used to obtain those outcomes, the defense bar needs to shift gears. The data is now more than sufficient to argue, at least with regard to defense experts, that Daubert is an unconstitutional barrier to a defendant’s right to call witnesses and to present a complete defense. The time has come to close the door on Daubert.
Full article available here.